This is a guest post by Derek from Derek Semmler dot com.
The other day Damien was discussing summer memories and asked about the strongest memory of your youth.
When my mind begins to wander through the collection of youthful summer memories, I immediately think of the flour fight that I had with my sister or the long summer days spent playing baseball with my buddies. Or the time that my best friend and I ran away from home, for all of three hours until we were caught when he insisted on sneaking home to use the bathroom.
While there are many pleasant memories that I could share with you, instead I want to discuss a not-so-fond memory from my youth and how I recently caught myself committing the same blunder with my children.
The essence of this memory is this: stop the criticism, inspire your children.
Throughout junior high and high school, I played football and hockey. While not the gifted athlete, I held my own pretty well in both sports and always put forth my best effort on game day.
After the game, I would usually catch a ride home with my dad. The memory that stands out to me about these post-game trips was not the acknowledgement of the goal I scored or the tackles that I made; but instead the criticism of how I should have scored two goals or how I missed three tackles. As a kid, I found this to be extremely frustrating and wanted to scream at my dad.
Looking back on these situations now, I understand that my dad meant well. He wanted the best for me and was attempting to offer his suggestions on how I could improve. But at the time I wanted no part of hearing the “help” that my dad was offering.
Now, here I am some 15+ years later and I recently caught myself following a similar pattern.
The Little League season just kicked off and my oldest son had his first game this past weekend. While he played a great game, making a nice play in the field and bringing in an RBI, he also had a few lapses.
As we walked to the car after the game, I shared with him that I thought he played a great game and then began to comment that he could have had two more hits had he not watched the ball and ran hard to first base. As I was beginning to tell him what he needed to do better, I had a flashback to the conversations that I had with my dad and I stopped in mid-sentence. When he looked at me, I just said that I thought he played great and I was proud of him.
When it comes to sports, I believe that many fathers want their son to be the superstar athlete – often times because they wanted to be themselves but never were. While the criticism is delivered with the best of intentions, unfortunately it rarely comes across as beneficial.
As parents, we need to stop the criticism of our children’s performance and instead offer our unconditional support and inspiration. If you feel that criticism is necessary, save it for a casual conversation days after the performance, not immediately afterwards on the trip home.
In an effort to inspire your children, try the following suggestions:
- Highlight the things that they have done well. Positive reinforcement of their performance will boost their confidence and they will revel in the fact that they have made you proud.
- Ask them how they feel they performed. Your child may very well be aware of things that they could have done better. Rather than offer your feedback, simply listening to them can be very rewarding.
- Be there for them. Is your child asking you to practice with them? Are you attending their performances? When your child looks for you, be there in full support of their activity.
The next time you find yourself beginning to criticize your child’s performance, stop yourself and offer a few encouraging words to inspire them to continue giving their best effort.
The memories will be much more enjoyable for both of you as a result.













6 Comments
Great post Derek, thanks again. I especially liked the thought “If you feel that criticism is necessary, save it for a casual conversation days after the performance, not immediately afterwards on the trip home.”
I have been wrestling with “waiting” to criticize and to parent until a better time. I tend to react wherever I am with my son. Since we parents are adults, we should be able to exercise restraint and think about what is really worth saying … a lot of the stuff I give my son is just thinking out loud and should it happen to be something that hurts his feelings, he will never forget it. I know this based on experiences with my own dad. Kids tend to remember the dark stuff and forget all the great memories. Solution? Lessen the number of dark times.
We’re in control now and that means responsibility. One day we’ll be in our empty houses praying our kids come to visit us. If we criticize them all the time, what good is that going to do them or us in 20 years?
Thanks for donating some dad energy to the Funny Farm, you blew this one out of the water man – I appreciate it! The best part about you guys guest posting is that I just get to kick back for few ;)
I fully agree with what you said. In addition, the encouragement to children is also important to their growth.
Great post Derek! Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us! I completely agree with you. I don’t have kids yet, but I see this issue happening between my parents and their younger kids and even between my mom and dad. My mom in law is the total opposite, she’s perfect this way, always listening and encouraging, just being there when you need to talk. That’s how I want to be. It’s so important to be a friend to your kids, not just their parent.
Katelyns last blog post..~Memories~
This is fantastic wisdom – it is awful how some parents get overworked about things like little league!! I find myself constantly remembering what it was like to be the kid now that I’m the mom and try to find that balance :) I’m going to have to read some other things you’ve written now!!
Chelles last blog post..8 Fun Ideas for Coloring Book Pages
Damien, thank you for opening your blog to me and granting me the floor to share with your community. It was a lot of fun to bring my dad spin to something that I thought would fit with some of the recent discussion.
@CC
@Katelyn
@Chelle :: Thanks for the kind words, I am happy to hear that you enjoyed the post. =)
Dereks last blog post..Manival And Alltop :: Men On The Interweb
Halleluia, Derek! This is one of my pet peeves. I have four teenagers and they all participate in competitive sports to some extent. My son plays almost every sport and if it’s not the coach criticizing something, it’s some parent watching the game.
Honestly, with my complete lack of sports skills, I think it’s fabulous that anyone could hit a ball with a bat to begin with, but these games are supposed to be fun.
If the kids have to worry about every little play or every mistake, it’s no fun anymore.
Your post was awesome!!!
Jessica The Rock Chis last blog post..Shuffle Off
2 Trackbacks
Recent Comments damien on Manival And Alltop :: Men On The InterwebStop The Criticism, Inspire Your Childrenon Connect With Your ChildMichael Beck on The Ultimate Twit List :: Dads & Husbands On Twitter
[...] Stop the criticism, inspire your children. [...]